Case: From the lasting existence of Paradise and Hell, someone concludes that they too must be beginningless and self-sufficient like Allah.
Allah is beginningless and independent by His very nature. Paradise and Hell are created and endure because He sustains them. Bestowed permanence of a creature is not the same as the Creator’s intrinsic eternity.
The reality and endurance of the final abodes can therefore be affirmed without dissolving the fundamental distinction between Creator and creation.