LessonsObligation Beyond Capacity: Possibility, Ability, and Moral JudgmentQuiz

Contraries become strictly incompatible only when subject, time, and relevant respect are the same. Someone may be seated and then standing; the two states occur in succession rather than at once.

A student may pass one subject while failing another. Although “pass” and “fail” oppose each other linguistically, there is no contradiction because they refer to different assessments.

Before declaring a proposition intrinsically impossible, determine whether the affirmation and negation apply to precisely the same thing in the same respect.

Opening interactive controls...

Why time and respect matter

Obligation Beyond Capacity: Possibility, Ability, and Moral Judgment

Contraries become strictly incompatible only when subject, time, and relevant respect are the same. Someone may be seated and then standing; the two states occur in succession rather than at once.

A student may pass one subject while failing another. Although “pass” and “fail” oppose each other linguistically, there is no contradiction because they refer to different assessments.

Before declaring a proposition intrinsically impossible, determine whether the affirmation and negation apply to precisely the same thing in the same respect.