LessonsProphetic Report, Miracles and Inferential KnowledgeQuiz

A person may acquire certainty about a prophetic statement through direct hearing or other personally conclusive circumstances, even where a later mass transmission is not involved. A companion's immediate audition is the clearest example.

This does not invalidate tawātur. It shows that mass transmission is not the only conceivable route by which a particular person can know the provenance of a statement. Some routes are public; others are restricted to an eyewitness or participant.

Understanding the sounds and understanding their precise meaning are further distinct tasks. Hearing authentic words does not guarantee infallible interpretation.

Opening interactive controls...

How an Individual May Know Without Tawatur

Prophetic Report, Miracles and Inferential Knowledge

A person may acquire certainty about a prophetic statement through direct hearing or other personally conclusive circumstances, even where a later mass transmission is not involved. A companion's immediate audition is the clearest example.

This does not invalidate tawātur. It shows that mass transmission is not the only conceivable route by which a particular person can know the provenance of a statement. Some routes are public; others are restricted to an eyewitness or participant.

Understanding the sounds and understanding their precise meaning are further distinct tasks. Hearing authentic words does not guarantee infallible interpretation.