إن الأول يثاب في الجنة، والثاني يعاقب في النار، والثالث لا يثاب ولا يعاقب
The first receives reward in Paradise, the second punishment in Hell, and the third neither reward nor punishment.
These are the proposed outcomes within the hypothetical exchange. Reward is related to obedience, punishment to disobedience, and the third case prompts the question of accountability before maturity. This is a reported premise in an argument, not a universal agreement among all theological schools on the fate of children.
A critical distinction: “not held accountable” and “not admitted to Paradise” are not the same claim. The following discussion sets out separate opinions and narrations about children's entrance into Paradise; the hypothetical answer must not be mistaken for the complete doctrinal treatment.