The opposite error associated with the doctrine of qadar in this contrast is to treat the human being as an independent creator of their own acts. Recognizing human choice does not mean that human beings bring their actions into existence independently of Allah.
Thus, the mistake of jabr denies human choice; the opposite mistake attributes independent creation of actions to the servant.
Human choice and Allah's creatorship are not mutually exclusive; they are affirmed in their proper senses.
Opening interactive controls...
The Balanced Path and Integrity of Belief
The opposite error associated with the doctrine of qadar in this contrast is to treat the human being as an independent creator of their own acts. Recognizing human choice does not mean that human beings bring their actions into existence independently of Allah.
Thus, the mistake of jabr denies human choice; the opposite mistake attributes independent creation of actions to the servant.
Human choice and Allah's creatorship are not mutually exclusive; they are affirmed in their proper senses.