LessonsThe Weighing, the Record, and the Questioning on Judgment DayQuiz

A common objection asks why questioning occurs if Allah already knows every act and intention. It assumes that the only purpose of a question is to discover an unknown fact. Questions may also elicit acknowledgment, disclose truth, establish responsibility, or make a judgment evident.

Divine knowledge: eternal, complete, and prior to all questioning.
Final questioning: a real confrontation of a person with actions and accountability.

There is therefore no contradiction unless questioning is first redefined as necessarily providing new knowledge to Allah, which is not the claim.

Opening interactive controls...

Why prior divine knowledge does not negate questioning

The Weighing, the Record, and the Questioning on Judgment Day

A common objection asks why questioning occurs if Allah already knows every act and intention. It assumes that the only purpose of a question is to discover an unknown fact. Questions may also elicit acknowledgment, disclose truth, establish responsibility, or make a judgment evident.

Divine knowledge: eternal, complete, and prior to all questioning.
Final questioning: a real confrontation of a person with actions and accountability.

There is therefore no contradiction unless questioning is first redefined as necessarily providing new knowledge to Allah, which is not the claim.