LessonsThe World and Its Origination: Creation and Philosophical EternityQuiz

A central philosophical premise states that prime matter cannot be wholly devoid of form, even if one form gives way to another. Philosophers use this premise in explaining a continuing substrate and successive forms.

But 'this matter cannot exist without some form' is not equivalent to 'this matter never began to exist'. A structural dependence between matter and form does not, by itself, prove the beginninglessness of the structure.

Two issues must therefore be tested separately: the claimed necessary connection between matter and form, and the further claim that their connection is eternal. The latter needs an argument of its own.

Opening interactive controls...

Can prime matter exist without form?

The World and Its Origination: Creation and Philosophical Eternity

A central philosophical premise states that prime matter cannot be wholly devoid of form, even if one form gives way to another. Philosophers use this premise in explaining a continuing substrate and successive forms.

But 'this matter cannot exist without some form' is not equivalent to 'this matter never began to exist'. A structural dependence between matter and form does not, by itself, prove the beginninglessness of the structure.

Two issues must therefore be tested separately: the claimed necessary connection between matter and form, and the further claim that their connection is eternal. The latter needs an argument of its own.