وَسَمَاحُكَ يُغِيثُ وَسَمَاؤُكَ تُغِيثُ
Your generosity brings rescue, and your sky brings welcome rain.
Composing under a constraint involving dotted and undotted letters requires more than ornamental vocabulary. The writer must preserve grammatical coherence, intelligibility, and rhetorical flow while satisfying an unusually strict formal demand.
When the previously marginal critic performs under such a condition, verbal competence becomes observable, not merely asserted. The achievement supports his claim to skill. It does not, by itself, demonstrate honesty in unrelated matters, a distinction important throughout the maqāmāt.