LessonsAl-Qasr: Real and Relative Restriction, Classifications and MethodsQuiz

قَصْرُ قَلْبٍ إِذَا اعْتَقَدَ الْعَكْسَ
Qalb is used when the listener believes the reverse of the intended judgment.

Suppose someone holds that Khalid is a poet rather than an orator, whereas the speaker intends to establish the opposite in that comparison. مَا خَالِدٌ إِلَّا خَطِيبٌ then does more than add a fact; it reverses the hearer's erroneous attribution.

In ifrad the hearer combined the alternatives. In qalb the hearer confidently assigned the wrong one. Distinguishing them requires attention to the listener’s belief.

Opening interactive controls...

Qalb: reversing an erroneous judgment

Al-Qasr: Real and Relative Restriction, Classifications and Methods

قَصْرُ قَلْبٍ إِذَا اعْتَقَدَ الْعَكْسَ
Qalb is used when the listener believes the reverse of the intended judgment.

Suppose someone holds that Khalid is a poet rather than an orator, whereas the speaker intends to establish the opposite in that comparison. مَا خَالِدٌ إِلَّا خَطِيبٌ then does more than add a fact; it reverses the hearer's erroneous attribution.

In ifrad the hearer combined the alternatives. In qalb the hearer confidently assigned the wrong one. Distinguishing them requires attention to the listener’s belief.