LessonsʿAṭf al-Bayān, Badal and Coordination: Clarifying, Reinforcing and Specifying the SubjectQuiz

جَاءَنِي أَخُوكَ زَيْدٌ
Your brother, Zayd, came to me.

Read as badal kull min kull (whole-for-whole substitution), both expressions denote one person. “Your brother” introduces him; “Zayd” reasserts the intended referent by name.

A superficially similar expression can sometimes be analyzed as explanatory apposition. Grammatical intent and contextual evidence, not the number of visible words alone, help determine the interpretation.

Opening interactive controls...

Whole-for-whole substitution

ʿAṭf al-Bayān, Badal and Coordination: Clarifying, Reinforcing and Specifying the Subject

جَاءَنِي أَخُوكَ زَيْدٌ
Your brother, Zayd, came to me.

Read as badal kull min kull (whole-for-whole substitution), both expressions denote one person. “Your brother” introduces him; “Zayd” reasserts the intended referent by name.

A superficially similar expression can sometimes be analyzed as explanatory apposition. Grammatical intent and contextual evidence, not the number of visible words alone, help determine the interpretation.