LessonsFasaha of Discourse: Weak Composition, Word Disharmony and ObscurityQuiz

Arabic does sometimes permit a pronoun to precede its referent in surface order; syntactic rank and the conditions of the construction can make such usage acceptable. Consequently, “every antecedent must always be mentioned first” is too crude a rule.

In the textbook case, the subject contains a pronoun pointing to a later object. The objections concern that specific configuration.

An academically sound method is to parse the verb, subject, object, and antecedent before evaluating which precedence relation actually holds.

Opening interactive controls...

A rule is not an absolute slogan

Fasaha of Discourse: Weak Composition, Word Disharmony and Obscurity

Arabic does sometimes permit a pronoun to precede its referent in surface order; syntactic rank and the conditions of the construction can make such usage acceptable. Consequently, “every antecedent must always be mentioned first” is too crude a rule.

In the textbook case, the subject contains a pronoun pointing to a later object. The objections concern that specific configuration.

An academically sound method is to parse the verb, subject, object, and antecedent before evaluating which precedence relation actually holds.