LessonsFronting the Subject: Restriction, Reinforcement and the al-Jurjani–al-Sakkaki DebateQuiz

ما أهر ذا ناب إلا شر
Nothing but an evil cause made a fanged creature growl.

The negative construction with إلا شر states a restriction involving the cause. The discussion cautions against treating the negation as a denial of every possible action by the animal: the utterance concerns a particular cause and its resulting response. The indefiniteness of «شر» can contribute to the impression of gravity.

Two devices are at work: restriction through exception and a rhetorical effect related to ordering and indefiniteness. Their contributions should not be collapsed into one.

Opening interactive controls...

Mā aharra dhā nāb: the purpose of a restrictive negative

Fronting the Subject: Restriction, Reinforcement and the al-Jurjani–al-Sakkaki Debate

ما أهر ذا ناب إلا شر
Nothing but an evil cause made a fanged creature growl.

The negative construction with إلا شر states a restriction involving the cause. The discussion cautions against treating the negation as a denial of every possible action by the animal: the utterance concerns a particular cause and its resulting response. The indefiniteness of «شر» can contribute to the impression of gravity.

Two devices are at work: restriction through exception and a rhetorical effect related to ordering and indefiniteness. Their contributions should not be collapsed into one.