LessonsIndefiniteness, Specification and Definiteness of the PredicateQuiz

Absence of restriction and absence of prior identification are related but distinct. The former avoids making a feature exclusive to one individual; the latter avoids identifying a particular previously known instance.

Examples:
«زَيْدٌ كَاتِبٌ» — Writing is attributed to Zayd without making him the only writer.
«زَيْدٌ رَجُلٌ» — Zayd is described as a man, without pointing to a specific previously known man.
«زَيْدٌ الْكَاتِبُ» — Context must now determine whether the known writer is being identified or writing is being restrictively predicated.

Thus moving from indefinite to definite is not merely adding al to a word; it can change the informational structure of the assertion.

Opening interactive controls...

Nonrestriction versus absence of prior identification

Indefiniteness, Specification and Definiteness of the Predicate

Absence of restriction and absence of prior identification are related but distinct. The former avoids making a feature exclusive to one individual; the latter avoids identifying a particular previously known instance.

Examples:
«زَيْدٌ كَاتِبٌ» — Writing is attributed to Zayd without making him the only writer.
«زَيْدٌ رَجُلٌ» — Zayd is described as a man, without pointing to a specific previously known man.
«زَيْدٌ الْكَاتِبُ» — Context must now determine whether the known writer is being identified or writing is being restrictively predicated.

Thus moving from indefinite to definite is not merely adding al to a word; it can change the informational structure of the assertion.