How do “sakita al-rajul” and “sakita al-rajul ḥīna suʾila ʿan ḥaqq ghayrih” differ?

Iʿtirāḍ and the Relative Measure of Ījāz and Iṭnāb — Concluding Volume 1

• They convey exactly identical reports
• The first is an adjective and the second a subject
• The second adds nothing relevant
• The second specifies the occasion and ethically relevant context