LessonsOther Interrogative Expressions: Different Objects of ConceptionQuiz

مَنْ جِبْرِيلُ؟
Who is Jibrīl?

مَلَكٌ
An angel.

The reply gives a kind or recognizable description rather than another proper name. It can still serve the question by making the individual identifiable to the listener.

Al-Sakkākī’s analysis faces an objection: a genus-like reply need not prove that the question was primarily about genus. The key analytical point is that a genus-like reply does not by itself eliminate the individuating function of man; the communicative context determines the required identification.

Opening interactive controls...

Man Jibrīl: a response beyond a proper name

Other Interrogative Expressions: Different Objects of Conception

مَنْ جِبْرِيلُ؟
Who is Jibrīl?

مَلَكٌ
An angel.

The reply gives a kind or recognizable description rather than another proper name. It can still serve the question by making the individual identifiable to the listener.

Al-Sakkākī’s analysis faces an objection: a genus-like reply need not prove that the question was primarily about genus. The key analytical point is that a genus-like reply does not by itself eliminate the individuating function of man; the communicative context determines the required identification.