LessonsProhibition (al-Nahy): Form, Literal Meaning and Rhetorical PurposesQuiz

“Lā tuṭiʿ amrī” can be a threat, but not every stern utterance abandons its literal meaning.

Genuine prohibition: A supervisor says “Lā tadkhul” — Do not enter. Entry is actually forbidden.
Permission: Someone says “In shiʾta fa-lā taʾti” — If you wish, you need not come. It may offer a choice.
Threat: An angry superior says “Lā tuṭiʿ amrī” — Disobey my instruction and face the consequences.

The distinction depends on evidence of forbidding, allowing, or warning of harm, not the presence of lā alone.

Opening interactive controls...

Threat, permission and genuine prohibition

Prohibition (al-Nahy): Form, Literal Meaning and Rhetorical Purposes

“Lā tuṭiʿ amrī” can be a threat, but not every stern utterance abandons its literal meaning.

Genuine prohibition: A supervisor says “Lā tadkhul” — Do not enter. Entry is actually forbidden.
Permission: Someone says “In shiʾta fa-lā taʾti” — If you wish, you need not come. It may offer a choice.
Threat: An angry superior says “Lā tuṭiʿ amrī” — Disobey my instruction and face the consequences.

The distinction depends on evidence of forbidding, allowing, or warning of harm, not the presence of lā alone.