LessonsProhibition: Refraining, Rhetorical Functions and Responses to RequestsQuiz

وَهُوَ كَالْأَمْرِ فِي الِاسْتِعْلَاءِ
Prohibition resembles command in the commanding stance.

Commands and prohibitions are both requestive utterances and, in their basic form, share a superior directive stance. They differ in the direction of requested conduct: command solicits doing; prohibition solicits refraining.

Uktub (“write”) and lā taktub (“do not write”) are both prospective directives. The distinction is not that one is “speech” and the other is “non-speech,” but whether performance or restraint is sought.

FeatureCommandProhibition
Requested outcomePerform an actRefrain from an act
FormIfʿalLā tafʿal
Shared featureRequest and directive stanceRequest and directive stance

Opening interactive controls...

Command versus prohibition

Prohibition: Refraining, Rhetorical Functions and Responses to Requests

وَهُوَ كَالْأَمْرِ فِي الِاسْتِعْلَاءِ
Prohibition resembles command in the commanding stance.

Commands and prohibitions are both requestive utterances and, in their basic form, share a superior directive stance. They differ in the direction of requested conduct: command solicits doing; prohibition solicits refraining.

Uktub (“write”) and lā taktub (“do not write”) are both prospective directives. The distinction is not that one is “speech” and the other is “non-speech,” but whether performance or restraint is sought.

FeatureCommandProhibition
Requested outcomePerform an actRefrain from an act
FormIfʿalLā tafʿal
Shared featureRequest and directive stanceRequest and directive stance