LessonsSupplementary Comprehensive Examination — Advanced Arabic Texts and Evidence-Based Rhetorical AnalysisQuiz

“Their trade did not profit” cannot be classified as attributional metaphor merely because commerce is not a human being. It is ordinary usage to say that a business profits or loses money.

A stronger analysis first describes how the passage depicts a disastrous moral exchange through the imagery of commerce. If an account of majāz ʿaqlī is proposed, the exact transfer of attribution must also be defended.

Rule: a non-human grammatical subject is not enough to establish majāz ʿaqlī.

Opening interactive controls...

Exam error 4: over-diagnosing attributional metaphor

Supplementary Comprehensive Examination — Advanced Arabic Texts and Evidence-Based Rhetorical Analysis

“Their trade did not profit” cannot be classified as attributional metaphor merely because commerce is not a human being. It is ordinary usage to say that a business profits or loses money.

A stronger analysis first describes how the passage depicts a disastrous moral exchange through the imagery of commerce. If an account of majāz ʿaqlī is proposed, the exact transfer of attribution must also be defended.

Rule: a non-human grammatical subject is not enough to establish majāz ʿaqlī.