LessonsSupplementary Practice 12: Rhetorical Evidence, Competing Analyses and Reasoned RevisionQuiz

رَأَيْتُ الْعُمَّالَ مُسْرِعِينَ.
I saw the workers while they were hurrying.

رَأَيْتُ الْعُمَّالَ الْمُسْرِعِينَ.
I saw the workers who were hurrying.

In the first expression, musriʿīna is an accusative circumstance describing the workers at the time of seeing them. In the second, al-musriʿīna is a definite attributive adjective modifying al-ʿummāla; it can help specify which workers are meant.

The shared lexical idea should not obscure the difference between a situation-bound circumstance and a noun's attribute. The speaker's purpose and the listener's question determine the most apt choice.

Opening interactive controls...

Circumstance versus an attribute of the noun

Supplementary Practice 12: Rhetorical Evidence, Competing Analyses and Reasoned Revision

رَأَيْتُ الْعُمَّالَ مُسْرِعِينَ.
I saw the workers while they were hurrying.

رَأَيْتُ الْعُمَّالَ الْمُسْرِعِينَ.
I saw the workers who were hurrying.

In the first expression, musriʿīna is an accusative circumstance describing the workers at the time of seeing them. In the second, al-musriʿīna is a definite attributive adjective modifying al-ʿummāla; it can help specify which workers are meant.

The shared lexical idea should not obscure the difference between a situation-bound circumstance and a noun's attribute. The speaker's purpose and the listener's question determine the most apt choice.