LessonsSupplementary Practice 13: Attribution, Quotation and Evidential Restraint in Rhetorical AnalysisQuiz

دَخَلَ الْمُحَقِّقُ يَحْمِلُ نُسْخَتَيْنِ.
The researcher entered carrying two copies.

Yaḥmilu nuskhatayni is an affirmative imperfect verbal clause describing the state accompanying entry. Its implicit subject refers to al-muḥaqqiq. In this construction the circumstantial verb clause suitably appears without the circumstantial wāw; adding wa-yaḥmilu would require a different contextual or syntactic explanation.

By contrast, dakhala al-muḥaqqiqu wa-huwa yaḥmilu nuskhatayni uses a nominal circumstantial clause with wāw and a pronoun. The comparison makes clear why the rule for an affirmative imperfect must not be applied indiscriminately to every clause containing an imperfect verb.

Opening interactive controls...

Affirmative imperfect used circumstantially

Supplementary Practice 13: Attribution, Quotation and Evidential Restraint in Rhetorical Analysis

دَخَلَ الْمُحَقِّقُ يَحْمِلُ نُسْخَتَيْنِ.
The researcher entered carrying two copies.

Yaḥmilu nuskhatayni is an affirmative imperfect verbal clause describing the state accompanying entry. Its implicit subject refers to al-muḥaqqiq. In this construction the circumstantial verb clause suitably appears without the circumstantial wāw; adding wa-yaḥmilu would require a different contextual or syntactic explanation.

By contrast, dakhala al-muḥaqqiqu wa-huwa yaḥmilu nuskhatayni uses a nominal circumstantial clause with wāw and a pronoun. The comparison makes clear why the rule for an affirmative imperfect must not be applied indiscriminately to every clause containing an imperfect verb.