What is the first analytical step when emphasis, substitution, and istiʾnāf all seem possible?
Supplementary Practice 3: Rhetorical Judgment, Contextual Evidence and Combined Devices
- Treat the presence of wāw as conclusive for all three
- Always interpret repeated words as evidence of substitution
- Determine what the second clause actually does to the earlier judgment
- Invent a contextless implied question and insist on istiʾnāf