A fall in purchasing power from 100 to 80 is not identical to total withdrawal of a currency from circulation. Quduri's case concerns the fact that people stopped transacting in the coins.
These three classical positions should therefore not automatically be applied to every instance of inflation or exchange-rate change. Contemporary currency questions require their own doctrinal and factual analysis.
Opening interactive controls...
Obsolescence is not ordinary depreciation
Bab al-Sarf: Mixed Currency Exchanges, Debased Coins and Obsolescence
A fall in purchasing power from 100 to 80 is not identical to total withdrawal of a currency from circulation. Quduri's case concerns the fact that people stopped transacting in the coins.
These three classical positions should therefore not automatically be applied to every instance of inflation or exchange-rate change. Contemporary currency questions require their own doctrinal and factual analysis.