Compare a pilgrim who omits saʿy entirely with one who completes only three circuits of the principal Hajj tawaf. The former has a valid Hajj with a prescribed offering; the latter has not completed the core tawaf threshold and cannot treat a penalty as a substitute for it.
Different rites occupy different positions in the legal structure of Hajj.
Opening interactive controls...
Bab Jinayat al-Muhrim — Tawaf Purity, Missed Rites and Expiations (Part III)
Compare a pilgrim who omits saʿy entirely with one who completes only three circuits of the principal Hajj tawaf. The former has a valid Hajj with a prescribed offering; the latter has not completed the core tawaf threshold and cannot treat a penalty as a substitute for it.
Different rites occupy different positions in the legal structure of Hajj.