Abu Hanifah and Muhammad require postponement of this Maghrib prayer to Muzdalifah under the quoted scenario. The phrase ʿinda Abī Ḥanīfata wa-Muḥammadin explicitly attributes that ruling to the two named jurists.
A source-critical lesson should not turn a specifically attributed ruling into an unconditional statement about every scholar, emergency, or modern Hajj procedure.
Opening interactive controls...
Book of Hajj: Prayers, Standing at Muzdalifah, and Departure to Mina
Abu Hanifah and Muhammad require postponement of this Maghrib prayer to Muzdalifah under the quoted scenario. The phrase ʿinda Abī Ḥanīfata wa-Muḥammadin explicitly attributes that ruling to the two named jurists.
A source-critical lesson should not turn a specifically attributed ruling into an unconditional statement about every scholar, emergency, or modern Hajj procedure.