Hanafi law does not treat the mere death of a creature without flowing blood in water as spoiling it. A differing ruling is reported from Shafi‘i concerning some non-fish creatures.
The disagreement asks whether impurity caused by death extends uniformly across species or whether categories are excluded based on blood characteristics and unavoidable circumstances.
Specific exceptions must be considered, so the different creatures should not all be collapsed into one broad rule.
Opening interactive controls...
Impurity in Stagnant and Running Water, Large Ponds, and Aquatic Creatures
Hanafi law does not treat the mere death of a creature without flowing blood in water as spoiling it. A differing ruling is reported from Shafi‘i concerning some non-fish creatures.
The disagreement asks whether impurity caused by death extends uniformly across species or whether categories are excluded based on blood characteristics and unavoidable circumstances.
Specific exceptions must be considered, so the different creatures should not all be collapsed into one broad rule.