LessonsInvalidators of Prayer, Part 1: Items 1–24Quiz

وَهُوَ ثَمَانِيَةٌ وَسِتُّونَ شَيْئًا

1–2. Speaking a word in prayer invalidates it even if the speech occurs forgetfully or by verbal mistake in the cases described by the chapter.
3. Dua with wording that resembles ordinary human requests invalidates the prayer. The commentary gives examples such as asking for a particular garment or a particular person in marriage. By contrast, requests such as forgiveness, pardon, well-being and provision from Allah are not treated as this invalidating human-style speech.
4. Giving Salaam as a greeting to a present person.
5. Verbally replying to Salaam.
6. Replying to Salaam by handshake.

Opening interactive controls...

Invalidators of Prayer, Part 1: Items 1–24

Read the bilingual lesson for Invalidators of Prayer, Part 1: Items 1–24 and test your understanding with a focused quiz.

Lesson

1. Items 1–6: Speech, Dua, and Salaam

وَهُوَ ثَمَانِيَةٌ وَسِتُّونَ شَيْئًا

1–2. Speaking a word in prayer invalidates it even if the speech occurs forgetfully or by verbal mistake in the cases described by the chapter.
3. Dua with wording that resembles ordinary human requests invalidates the prayer. The commentary gives examples such as asking for a particular garment or a particular person in marriage. By contrast, requests such as forgiveness, pardon, well-being and provision from Allah are not treated as this invalidating human-style speech.
4. Giving Salaam as a greeting to a present person.
5. Verbally replying to Salaam.
6. Replying to Salaam by handshake.

2. Items 7–11: Action, Qiblah, Eating and Drinking

7. Amal Kathir — excessive action. The preferred definition given by the commentary is an action pattern that makes an observer have no doubt that the person is not in prayer; if the observer could still reasonably be unsure, it is treated as little action.
8. Turning the chest away from the Qiblah without a valid legal necessity.
9. Eating anything introduced from outside the mouth, even a small amount.
10. Eating food already between the teeth when it is a large amount — classically, about the size of a chickpea.
11. Drinking.

3. Items 12–17: Throat Sounds, Groaning and Crying

12. Unnecessary throat-clearing that produces letters/speech-like sound in the legally relevant manner.
13. Saying sounds such as “uff”.
14. Groaning.
15. Sighing/moaning.
16–17. Audible crying because of bodily pain or worldly calamity.

The text expressly excludes crying that rises from remembrance of Paradise or Hell. The legal distinction is therefore not simply “all crying breaks prayer.”

4. Items 18–24: Replies and Deliberate Message-Responses

18. Saying يَرْحَمُكَ الله to a person who sneezes.
19. Answering a question about whether there is a rival to Allah by saying لَا إِلٰهَ إِلَّا الله as the reply.
20. Responding to bad news with Istirja' as an answer.
21. Responding to good news with الْحَمْدُ لِلَّه as an answer.
22–23. Responding to surprise with سُبْحَانَ الله or لَا إِلٰهَ إِلَّا الله when intended as the answer.
24. Any Quranic wording deliberately intended as an answer to another person's request — the text gives the example of reciting “O Yahya, take the Book” to someone asking for a book.

The issue is the intention to use the utterance as interpersonal speech, not the sacred wording by itself.

5. Items 1–24 at a Glance

1–2 speech; 3 human-style dua; 4 greeting Salaam; 5 verbal reply to Salaam; 6 handshake reply; 7 excessive action; 8 chest away from Qiblah; 9 outside food; 10 large food remnant between teeth; 11 drinking; 12 needless throat-clearing; 13 “uff”; 14 groaning; 15 sighing; 16 crying from pain; 17 crying from calamity; 18 blessing a sneezer; 19–23 verbal responses to outside information; 24 Quranic wording deliberately used as an interpersonal answer.

Practice questions

Question 1

How many invalidators does the author state in this teaching list?

  • 68.
  • 58.
  • 18.
  • 77.

Question 2

Saying “O Allah, forgive me and grant me well-being” invalidates the prayer merely because it contains a request.

  • True
  • False

Question 3

Which action is the preferred definition of Amal Kathir in the commentary?

  • An action pattern that leaves an observer in no doubt that the person is not in prayer.
  • Exactly any movement repeated twice.
  • Any blink of the eyes.
  • Any movement of one finger.

Question 4

Eating a tiny remnant already between the teeth that is below the stated chickpea-size threshold necessarily invalidates the prayer even without excessive action.

  • True
  • False

Question 5

Which crying is expressly excluded from the invalidating crying listed here?

  • Crying from remembrance of Paradise or Hell.
  • Every cry caused by worldly loss.
  • Every groan from physical pain.
  • All loud crying without exception.

Question 6

Verbally replying to a Salaam during prayer invalidates the prayer.

  • True
  • False

Question 7

What is the key reason a Quranic phrase can become an invalidating response in item 24?

  • It is deliberately intended as an interpersonal answer to someone.
  • Every recited passage is forbidden during prayer.
  • The verse is too short.
  • Only because it is recited silently.

Question 8

Turning only the eyes to the side without turning the chest is the same invalidator as turning the chest away from Qiblah.

  • True
  • False

Open the interactive quiz