Abu Hanifah considers the uncounted “one dirham per qafiz” sale valid for one qafiz alone.
Abu Yusuf and Muhammad, the Sahibayn, allow the sale of the whole heap: its exact amount and total price can be established by measurement.
Quduri's quoted clause names Abu Hanifah's position. The disciples' contrasting view is supplied by al-Hidaya and Fath al-Qadir, not attributed to the short original passage.
Opening interactive controls...
Kitab al-Buyu: Grain Sales, Bulk Heaps, Qafiz and Unit Prices
Abu Hanifah considers the uncounted “one dirham per qafiz” sale valid for one qafiz alone.
Abu Yusuf and Muhammad, the Sahibayn, allow the sale of the whole heap: its exact amount and total price can be established by measurement.
Quduri's quoted clause names Abu Hanifah's position. The disciples' contrasting view is supplied by al-Hidaya and Fath al-Qadir, not attributed to the short original passage.