Abu Hanifah: No general interdiction for debt; payment may be compelled, with a defined exception for applying or converting monetary holdings.
Abu Yusuf and Muhammad: On creditors’ petition, a judge may interdict harmful transactions, sell property when necessary, and distribute proceeds proportionately.
Both sides affirm enforceable debts and creditor rights. The disagreement concerns judicial remedies and the scope of restrictions on an otherwise competent debtor.
Opening interactive controls...
Comparing the positions accurately
Kitab al-Hajr: Insolvency, Interdiction and Creditors’ Rights
Abu Hanifah: No general interdiction for debt; payment may be compelled, with a defined exception for applying or converting monetary holdings.
Abu Yusuf and Muhammad: On creditors’ petition, a judge may interdict harmful transactions, sell property when necessary, and distribute proceeds proportionately.
Both sides affirm enforceable debts and creditor rights. The disagreement concerns judicial remedies and the scope of restrictions on an otherwise competent debtor.