Until now, the initial admission and the exception have both been denominated in dirhams. Al-Quduri now considers an admission of 100 dirhams with an exception expressed as one dinar or a qafiz of wheat.
You cannot subtract “one item” from “100 coins” as if the units match. We must ask whether the cross-kind exception is valid, how its value in dirhams is measured, and whether every type of item—such as a garment—qualifies.
Opening interactive controls...
A new question: excluding a different kind
Kitab al-Iqrar: Connected Exceptions, Quantities, and Cross-Category Exceptions
Until now, the initial admission and the exception have both been denominated in dirhams. Al-Quduri now considers an admission of 100 dirhams with an exception expressed as one dinar or a qafiz of wheat.
You cannot subtract “one item” from “100 coins” as if the units match. We must ask whether the cross-kind exception is valid, how its value in dirhams is measured, and whether every type of item—such as a garment—qualifies.