1. A valid exception connected to an admission is effective and leaves the remainder binding.
2. The excluded portion may be smaller than, equal to or greater than half; excluding the full same-kind amount is invalid.
3. Deduction for a dinar or a qafiz of wheat from 100 dirhams uses their relevant monetary value, rather than their bare count, according to Abu Hanifa and Abu Yusuf.
4. Imam Muhammad disagrees about these cross-kind examples, and a garment exception is invalid under the Hanafi positions discussed.
The next level treats phrases such as “one hundred and a dirham” and “one hundred and a garment,” where conjunction affects interpretation.
Opening interactive controls...
Consolidating the rules
Kitab al-Iqrar: Connected Exceptions, Quantities, and Cross-Category Exceptions
1. A valid exception connected to an admission is effective and leaves the remainder binding.
2. The excluded portion may be smaller than, equal to or greater than half; excluding the full same-kind amount is invalid.
3. Deduction for a dinar or a qafiz of wheat from 100 dirhams uses their relevant monetary value, rather than their bare count, according to Abu Hanifa and Abu Yusuf.
4. Imam Muhammad disagrees about these cross-kind examples, and a garment exception is invalid under the Hanafi positions discussed.
The next level treats phrases such as “one hundred and a dirham” and “one hundred and a garment,” where conjunction affects interpretation.