There are three named jurists but two rulings: Abu Hanifah—fast remains valid; Muhammad—fast remains valid; Abu Yusuf—fast is invalidated. The names must accompany the views.
Underlying analysis concerns the legal significance of penetration and reach by this route. The lesson preserves the distinction without treating it as an anatomical ruling about every modern urethral procedure.
Opening interactive controls...
Kitab al-Sawm: Medication Routes, Treatment, and Fasting Rulings
There are three named jurists but two rulings: Abu Hanifah—fast remains valid; Muhammad—fast remains valid; Abu Yusuf—fast is invalidated. The names must accompany the views.
Underlying analysis concerns the legal significance of penetration and reach by this route. The lesson preserves the distinction without treating it as an anatomical ruling about every modern urethral procedure.