LessonsPrayer in, Around, and on the Roof of the KaabaQuiz

Hanafi position: Both obligatory and voluntary prayers are valid because facing a recognized part of the qibla is possible inside the Kaaba.

A reported Maliki view: Voluntary prayer is allowed inside, but obligatory prayer is not valid, reflecting a stricter application of the qibla condition to obligations.

A view attributed to al-Shafi‘i in this edition: Does not allow prayer inside. The attribution is presented as reported here; the wider Shafi‘i school has more detailed discussion.

Opening interactive controls...

Juristic disagreement over obligatory prayer inside

Prayer in, Around, and on the Roof of the Kaaba

Hanafi position: Both obligatory and voluntary prayers are valid because facing a recognized part of the qibla is possible inside the Kaaba.

A reported Maliki view: Voluntary prayer is allowed inside, but obligatory prayer is not valid, reflecting a stricter application of the qibla condition to obligations.

A view attributed to al-Shafi‘i in this edition: Does not allow prayer inside. The attribution is presented as reported here; the wider Shafi‘i school has more detailed discussion.