LessonsSalat al-Istisqa: Supplication for Rain and Juristic RulingsQuiz

Hanafi ruling: the imam turns his cloak; the people do not. The explicit phrase from the matn makes the distinction.

Al-Shafi‘i and Malik are reported to extend the practice to the congregation as following the imam in this symbolic act. The dispute is about whether imitation covers this particular gesture.

Opening interactive controls...

Why the followers do not turn theirs

Salat al-Istisqa: Supplication for Rain and Juristic Rulings

Hanafi ruling: the imam turns his cloak; the people do not. The explicit phrase from the matn makes the distinction.

Al-Shafi‘i and Malik are reported to extend the practice to the congregation as following the imam in this symbolic act. The dispute is about whether imitation covers this particular gesture.