Pig su’r is impure. Its underlying rationale is not identical in every detail to the dog case: for dogs the vessel-washing report is central, while impurity inherent to the pig is part of the reasoning for its saliva.
Both are classed impure in the Hanafi result, but the proofs are not simply identical.
Opening interactive controls...
Su’r: Categories, Purity, and Juristic Differences
Pig su’r is impure. Its underlying rationale is not identical in every detail to the dog case: for dogs the vessel-washing report is central, while impurity inherent to the pig is part of the reasoning for its saliva.
Both are classed impure in the Hanafi result, but the proofs are not simply identical.