Reports ascribed to Ibn ‘Abbas point toward purity while others ascribed to Ibn ‘Umar point toward impurity. Their differing implications contribute to the doubtful status.
The argument balances the original presumption about water against uncertainty concerning the effect of saliva, leading to a combined precaution.
Opening interactive controls...
Su’r: Categories, Purity, and Juristic Differences
Reports ascribed to Ibn ‘Abbas point toward purity while others ascribed to Ibn ‘Umar point toward impurity. Their differing implications contribute to the doubtful status.
The argument balances the original presumption about water against uncertainty concerning the effect of saliva, leading to a combined precaution.