How does «samiʿtu ʿIkrimah» differ from «ʿan ʿIkrimah»?
Criticism of Transmitters: Misreporting, Claims of Hearing and Historical Evidence
- “Samiʿtu” expressly claims personal hearing
- Both explicitly assert direct audition in all cases
- “ʿAn” necessarily establishes deliberate lying
- “Samiʿtu” states only contemporaneity