Both points matter in the definition:
• The other Hadith has an opposing meaning. A Hadith supporting the same point is not an opposing one.
• The opposing Hadith has equal standing. Someone merely saying the opposite does not meet this condition.
Muḥkam therefore does not mean that no other Hadith exists on that topic.
Opening interactive controls...
Muḥkam Hadith: Definition and Example
Both points matter in the definition:
• The other Hadith has an opposing meaning. A Hadith supporting the same point is not an opposing one.
• The opposing Hadith has equal standing. Someone merely saying the opposite does not meet this condition.
Muḥkam therefore does not mean that no other Hadith exists on that topic.