Al-Haythamī described Ḥabīb ibn Ḥabīb as weak. His report here opposes the other reliable transmission: the others reported Ibn ʿAbbās's statement; he attributed it to the Prophet ﷺ.
• The mawqūf report stopping at Ibn ʿAbbās is maʿrūf here.
• The marfūʿ version attributed to the Prophet ﷺ is munkar here.
Abū Zurʿah also called it munkar and explained that it is mawqūf from Ibn ʿAbbās.
Opening interactive controls...
Munkar: A weak report opposing a reliable report
Al-Haythamī described Ḥabīb ibn Ḥabīb as weak. His report here opposes the other reliable transmission: the others reported Ibn ʿAbbās's statement; he attributed it to the Prophet ﷺ.
• The mawqūf report stopping at Ibn ʿAbbās is maʿrūf here.
• The marfūʿ version attributed to the Prophet ﷺ is munkar here.
Abū Zurʿah also called it munkar and explained that it is mawqūf from Ibn ʿAbbās.