LessonsMutaba‘ah, Shahid and I‘tibar: Tracing Hadith Transmission RoutesQuiz

Al-Bukhari transmits a relevant version through ‘Abd Allah b. Maslamah al-Qa‘nabi ← Malik ← ‘Abd Allah b. Dinar ← Ibn ‘Umar, including the instruction to complete the count to thirty.

Al-Qa‘nabi and al-Shafi‘i are both direct pupils of Malik. Hence the route via al-Qa‘nabi constitutes a complete mutaba‘ah for al-Shafi‘i and removes the claim that only al-Shafi‘i supplied that wording from Malik.

The example shows why matching subject matter is not enough by itself: one must specify the point at which the two chains converge.

Opening interactive controls...

The route through al-Qa‘nabi: complete mutaba‘ah

Mutaba‘ah, Shahid and I‘tibar: Tracing Hadith Transmission Routes

Al-Bukhari transmits a relevant version through ‘Abd Allah b. Maslamah al-Qa‘nabi ← Malik ← ‘Abd Allah b. Dinar ← Ibn ‘Umar, including the instruction to complete the count to thirty.

Al-Qa‘nabi and al-Shafi‘i are both direct pupils of Malik. Hence the route via al-Qa‘nabi constitutes a complete mutaba‘ah for al-Shafi‘i and removes the claim that only al-Shafi‘i supplied that wording from Malik.

The example shows why matching subject matter is not enough by itself: one must specify the point at which the two chains converge.