How does Shuʿbah argue against al-Ḥasan b. ʿUmārah in report 74?
Narrator Criticism: Teacher Verification, Conflicting Ascriptions and Claims of Hearing
- By relying only on the notoriety of his doctrinal affiliation
- By comparing alleged reports from al-Ḥakam with al-Ḥakam’s own replies
- By establishing juristic consensus against every variant wording
- By dismissing every route merely because chains differ