LessonsSahih li-Dhatihi: Authenticity Conditions, Narrator Precision and Chain RankingsQuiz

Sahih li-dhatihi requires complete precision. By contrast, in hasan li-dhatihi the narrator is upright and the transmission retains the basic conditions of acceptability, but his precision is somewhat below that of a sahih-grade transmitter. This does not mean that he is generally unreliable or habitually mistaken.

Technical comparison:
Upright + fully precise + continuous chain + no disqualifying ʿillah or shudhudh → sahih li-dhatihi.
Upright + somewhat reduced but acceptable precision + remaining conditions → hasan li-dhatihi.

Application: A transmitter may be mostly accurate but not quite as exact as the highest-ranked narrators; this can lower a report from sahih to hasan. Severe or frequent mistakes cannot be rebranded as minor reduction in precision merely to retain an accepted classification.

Opening interactive controls...

Complete versus lesser precision in sahih and hasan

Sahih li-Dhatihi: Authenticity Conditions, Narrator Precision and Chain Rankings

Sahih li-dhatihi requires complete precision. By contrast, in hasan li-dhatihi the narrator is upright and the transmission retains the basic conditions of acceptability, but his precision is somewhat below that of a sahih-grade transmitter. This does not mean that he is generally unreliable or habitually mistaken.

Technical comparison:
Upright + fully precise + continuous chain + no disqualifying ʿillah or shudhudh → sahih li-dhatihi.
Upright + somewhat reduced but acceptable precision + remaining conditions → hasan li-dhatihi.

Application: A transmitter may be mostly accurate but not quite as exact as the highest-ranked narrators; this can lower a report from sahih to hasan. Severe or frequent mistakes cannot be rebranded as minor reduction in precision merely to retain an accepted classification.