If two routes give “Zayd ʿan Khālid” and a third “Zayd ʿan Bakr ʿan Khālid,” which possibilities must be investigated?
The Muqaddimah’s Aim: Mastery, Selection, and Critical Comparison
- Two shorter routes automatically prove the extra intermediary mistaken
- Examine possible omission, mistaken insertion, or genuine hearing by both routes
- An extra intermediary makes the shorter routes disconnected without further inquiry
- The number of routes conclusively establishes connection without hearing evidence