What is the status of “bi-ḥasbi al-marʾ ...” attributed to ʿUmar?
The Prohibition on Relating Everything Heard: Verification, Selection and Audience
- A Companion’s statement, not independently marfūʿ in this route
- Mālik’s legal definition
- A Prophetic report through Ibn Masʿūd
- A denial of the transmitted matn on grounds of precision