The chapter combines a Prophetic report, statements of ʿUmar and Ibn Masʿūd, and scholarly advice from Mālik, ʿAbd al-Raḥmān b. Mahdī and Iyās. Their ethical direction converges, but their levels of attribution are not identical.
Say “reported from the Prophet,” “ʿUmar stated,” or “Mālik advised,” as appropriate. Accurate attribution is the constructive practice that answers the prohibition on indiscriminate transmission.
Opening interactive controls...
The Prohibition on Relating Everything Heard: Verification, Selection and Audience
The chapter combines a Prophetic report, statements of ʿUmar and Ibn Masʿūd, and scholarly advice from Mālik, ʿAbd al-Raḥmān b. Mahdī and Iyās. Their ethical direction converges, but their levels of attribution are not identical.
Say “reported from the Prophet,” “ʿUmar stated,” or “Mālik advised,” as appropriate. Accurate attribution is the constructive practice that answers the prohibition on indiscriminate transmission.