If continuity remains uncertain in a chain, what is the proper scholarly response?
Trustworthy Transmission, the Report of a Fāsiq, and Responsible Narration
- Treat any doubt as discontinuity and then label the report fabricated
- Treat two corroborators as obviating examination of hearing
- Investigate continuity and relevant evidence before affirming authenticity
- Regard simple contemporaneity as conclusively proving every connection