LessonsCategorical Propositions: Singular, Natural, Quantified and Indefinite FormsQuiz

«بعض الحيوان أسود»
Some animals are black.

“Some” designates part of the animal class, and blackness is affirmed of those instances. This is a particular affirmative.

“Some students have memorized the Qur’an” asserts that at least some students have that property. It does not entail that all remaining students lack it; the claim simply makes no commitment about them.

Thus logical “some” should not be confused with a conversational suggestion that the remaining members must be excluded.

Opening interactive controls...

Particular affirmative: some S are P

Categorical Propositions: Singular, Natural, Quantified and Indefinite Forms

«بعض الحيوان أسود»
Some animals are black.

“Some” designates part of the animal class, and blackness is affirmed of those instances. This is a particular affirmative.

“Some students have memorized the Qur’an” asserts that at least some students have that property. It does not entail that all remaining students lack it; the claim simply makes no commitment about them.

Thus logical “some” should not be confused with a conversational suggestion that the remaining members must be excluded.