LessonsModal Propositions: The Eight Simple ModalitiesQuiz

These two forms are close because both are qualified by the subject's titular description, yet their logical force differs.

General conditional: the relation is necessary while that description holds.
General customary: the relation is permanent while that description holds.

Suppose a “teacher” is considered precisely while teaching. “While teaching, the person continually speaks” may be a claim about continuity, but it does not thereby express logical necessity; one may teach by writing or gestures.

The key is to separate the duration of a condition from the force of the predication.

Opening interactive controls...

Conditional and customary: same scope, different force

Modal Propositions: The Eight Simple Modalities

These two forms are close because both are qualified by the subject's titular description, yet their logical force differs.

General conditional: the relation is necessary while that description holds.
General customary: the relation is permanent while that description holds.

Suppose a “teacher” is considered precisely while teaching. “While teaching, the person continually speaks” may be a claim about continuity, but it does not thereby express logical necessity; one may teach by writing or gestures.

The key is to separate the duration of a condition from the force of the predication.