LessonsPredication, Types of Categorical Proposition and Negated TermsQuiz

Maʿdūlah does not mean that the overall proposition must be affirmative. The book explicitly divides both affirmative and negative propositions into metathetic and non-metathetic forms.

Consider “This person is not a non-scholar”:
Predicate: “non-scholar,” a negated concept.
Connection: “is not,” which denies that predicate of the subject.

Thus a negated term and a negative judgment can occur together. They are not redundant simply because both contain negation; their logical roles are different.

Opening interactive controls...

How can a negative proposition also be metathetic?

Predication, Types of Categorical Proposition and Negated Terms

Maʿdūlah does not mean that the overall proposition must be affirmative. The book explicitly divides both affirmative and negative propositions into metathetic and non-metathetic forms.

Consider “This person is not a non-scholar”:
Predicate: “non-scholar,” a negated concept.
Connection: “is not,” which denies that predicate of the subject.

Thus a negated term and a negative judgment can occur together. They are not redundant simply because both contain negation; their logical roles are different.