LessonsQiyās al-Khalf: Compound Reductio, Impossibility and Proof of the ClaimQuiz

Claim: Every square has four sides.
Contradictory: Some square does not have four sides.

By definition, a square is a four-sided figure with equal sides and right angles. Assuming a square that does not have four sides conflicts with the very definition used to identify it as a square.

The assumed contradictory is therefore rejected. Here having four sides belongs to the definition of the square, not to a merely observed regularity.

Opening interactive controls...

Worked supplementary example: square sides

Qiyās al-Khalf: Compound Reductio, Impossibility and Proof of the Claim

Claim: Every square has four sides.
Contradictory: Some square does not have four sides.

By definition, a square is a four-sided figure with equal sides and right angles. Assuming a square that does not have four sides conflicts with the very definition used to identify it as a square.

The assumed contradictory is therefore rejected. Here having four sides belongs to the definition of the square, not to a merely observed regularity.