LessonsRhetorical Syllogism: Accepted, Probable Premises and PersuasionQuiz

The text makes a special distinction:

وأما المأخوذات من الأنبياء فليست من الخطابة
Reports received from prophets are not classified here as merely rhetorical premises.

Within the book’s classical Islamic framework, prophetic truthfulness established through miracles means an authentically established prophetic statement is treated as a certain premise, not merely as a respected person’s probable testimony.

Establishing that a statement really comes from a prophet and interpreting it correctly remain distinct questions. The source’s point is to separate prophetic authority, under its stated premises, from ordinary accepted reports.

Opening interactive controls...

The text’s special treatment of prophetic reports

Rhetorical Syllogism: Accepted, Probable Premises and Persuasion

The text makes a special distinction:

وأما المأخوذات من الأنبياء فليست من الخطابة
Reports received from prophets are not classified here as merely rhetorical premises.

Within the book’s classical Islamic framework, prophetic truthfulness established through miracles means an authentically established prophetic statement is treated as a certain premise, not merely as a respected person’s probable testimony.

Establishing that a statement really comes from a prophet and interpreting it correctly remain distinct questions. The source’s point is to separate prophetic authority, under its stated premises, from ordinary accepted reports.